Not legal or tax advice — rules vary by state and change; the specifics below reflect what I learned setting this up in Wisconsin. Confirm your state's rules with your accountant before hiring.

The first hire is the scariest decision in a solo trade business, partly because the internet's standard advice — "just 1099 a guy" — ranges from risky to illegal. Here's the honest version.

When to hire — a calendar rule, not a feelings rule. Pull the trigger when your booked schedule (signed, deposited jobs — not your hopes) is consistently more than 3–4 weeks deep and you're declining or delaying work. Hire on pipeline, not optimism: a helper hired into a thin calendar is overhead with a heartbeat. Corollary: if quotes are your bottleneck rather than installs, fix quoting speed first — it's cheaper than payroll and might be the capacity you needed.

The 1099 fantasy. Calling your regular helper an independent contractor feels cheaper — no payroll taxes, no workers' comp, no paperwork. The problem: the label doesn't decide the classification; the working relationship does. States apply multi-factor tests (Wisconsin's is famously strict — a nine-part test where the worker generally needs to look like an actual independent business: their own tools and equipment, their own other customers, real profit/loss exposure, invoicing you like a vendor). A guy who shows up in your truck, uses your auger, works your schedule, on your jobs, only for you, is an employee no matter what the handshake said. Misclassification surfaces at the worst moments — an injury, an unemployment claim, an audit — and arrives with back taxes, premiums, and penalties attached. The honest test: a legitimate 1099 sub could replace you on the job and doesn't need you to function. Your Tuesday-through-Saturday helper fails that test.

What W2 actually costs (the real loaded rate): wage + employer payroll taxes (roughly 8–10%) + workers' comp — and fencing payroll carries real comp rates, plan on the order of $8–15 per $100 of payroll depending on state and class code + a little admin (a payroll service runs $40–80/mo and is worth every cent). Net effect: a $22/hr helper costs you roughly $26–29/hr loaded. Price your jobs off the loaded number from day one.

Does the math work? Almost always, if the calendar's full. A second set of hands doesn't add 100% capacity — it adds more, because two-person tasks (panels, layout, long runs) stop being slow one-person tasks. If a helper takes you from 2 installs a week to 3–4, the gross margin on the added jobs swallows the loaded wage with room to spare. Run your own version: added jobs/month × margin/job vs. monthly loaded cost. The hire usually pays for itself within the first month of a full calendar — which is why the calendar rule comes first.

Where legitimate 1099 lives: true specialty subs — the concrete finisher with his own outfit, the surveyor, an established fence sub with his own crew, insurance, and customers. Vendors, not helpers.

First-hire hygiene: workers' comp bound before the first hour (in Wisconsin the obligation can trigger fast once real wages are paid — don't try to time the threshold), payroll service from day one, a one-page job expectations sheet, and two weeks of working side-by-side before they touch a job representing your name alone.

The first hire is also the moment your quoting, pricing, and job documentation stop being "your memory" and need to be a system someone else can follow. That's not a software pitch — it's just what payroll does to a business. (Okay, it's a little bit of a software pitch.)

Pricing that already includes loaded labor, and job docs a new hire can follow: See Fenceworks →

Written by Rob Diederich, founder of Fenceworks.ai and Kodiak Fence Co.

Get the new hire productive